Gifts and holidays

How to Gather Your Family's Old Tapes at Thanksgiving

The tapes are usually split between three closets in three different houses. Thanksgiving is the one day everyone who knows where they are is sitting at the same table.

A Thanksgiving table set with amber glass dishes, cranberry sauce, a lit candle and a pinecone turkey
A Thanksgiving table set and waiting, 2010. Photo: vxla / Flickr, CC BY 2.0

QUICK ANSWER

Ask relatives a week ahead to bring any home video tapes, camcorder tapes, audio cassettes or film reels they have. At the gathering, make one written list of every tape, who owns it and what's on it, and ask the older relatives to fill in names and dates while they're there. Then choose one person to carry the tapes home, get them digitized together, and share the files with everyone.

When people call me about old home movies, they often aren't sure where all the tapes are. Mom had a box, a brother took a few, an aunt might have the rest. The tapes from one family are usually scattered across several houses, sometimes several states.

That's why Thanksgiving is such a good chance to sort it out. It's often the one day of the year when everyone who knows where the tapes are, and what's on them, is in the same room. A little planning before the day turns "we should really do something with those tapes" into a box in your trunk on the drive home.

Here's a simple way to do it.

Why Thanksgiving is the right time to gather the tapes

Three reasons.

First, the people are there. The relatives who filmed the birthdays and Christmases are the ones who can tell you what's on an unlabeled tape. Years from now, with those relatives gone, it's much harder to find out who that is holding the baby.

Second, the tapes are close by. Many families gather at a parent's or grandparent's house, and that's where the tapes are usually sitting, in a hall closet, under the TV stand or up in the attic.

Third, it gives you time. If you collect the tapes at Thanksgiving, there's still time to have them digitized before Christmas. More on that below.

Before Thanksgiving: send a short message

Don't spring it on people at the table. About a week before, send one short message to the family group text or email. Something like:

"I'd like to get our old home movies digitized so everybody can have a copy. If you have any old tapes or reels, could you bring them Thursday? Even the unlabeled ones."

Then tell them what to look for. Most people only think of big VHS tapes and forget the rest:

  • VHS tapes, the full-size ones, including tapes recorded off TV that might have family footage on the end.
  • Small camcorder tapes: VHS-C (a small tape that fits in an adapter), 8mm cassettes and MiniDV. If you're not sure what you have, our guide on camcorder tape transfers shows the common ones.
  • Audio cassettes, especially ones with voices on them: recorded letters, church services, a grandparent singing.
  • Film reels in small metal or plastic cans.

You can skip the store-bought movies. It's the home recordings you're after.

Ask people to check the less obvious places too: basements, attics, garages, cedar chests and the drawer under the old VCR. Tapes stored in hot or damp spots are the ones most at risk, so they're worth finding first. If you're curious why, our article on how long VHS tapes last explains what heat and humidity do to them.

At the gathering: make one list

A TDK VHS cassette with a handwritten label
A VHS cassette with a handwritten label. Photo: Ggga21 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

When the tapes arrive, resist the urge to dig out an old VCR and start playing them. A dusty machine that hasn't run in years can chew up a fragile tape. Instead, spend fifteen minutes making a list. It's the single most useful thing you can do that day.

A sheet of paper works fine. A note on your phone is even better, because you can text it to everyone afterward. For each tape, write down:

What to write Example
A number 14
Who brought it Aunt Carol
What kind of tape VHS-C
What the label says "Lake 1991"
What people think is on it Uncle Jim's 40th birthday at the lake
Anything wrong with it Rattles, tape looks crinkled

Put the same number on the tape itself with a small piece of masking tape. That way the list and the tapes stay matched even after they've been boxed up and moved.

Note any tape that looks damaged, smells musty, or has white spots on the tape. Don't throw it out and don't try to fix it. Just keep it apart and mention it when you send the tapes in.

Ask the older relatives while they're there

This is the part you can't do later.

A dining table set for Thanksgiving beneath a hand-decorated Happy Thanksgiving sign
A dining room set for Thanksgiving dinner, 2010. Photo: liz west / Flickr, CC BY 2.0

Pass the list to the grandparents, aunts and uncles and ask them to fill in what they know: who's on each tape, roughly what year, where it was filmed. The Smithsonian Institution Archives suggests asking older relatives to clarify names, because names are what get lost first. A label that says "Christmas" means nothing to a grandchild in 30 years. "Christmas 1987, Grandma's house in Columbia, with the cousins from Memphis" means a lot.

If you want to go a step further, the same Smithsonian article suggests showing some old home movies and recording the stories they bring back. It recommends finding a quiet room, turning off phones and the football game, and starting each recording by saying who is talking, who's asking the questions, when and where. Your phone's voice recorder is plenty.

Not sure how to get people talking? American Ancestors, a family history organization, publishes a list of Thanksgiving conversation prompts, such as asking whether someone was named after another relative, or who was the oldest relative they ever got to meet. Questions like those pair naturally with old footage.

Decide who handles the tapes, and who keeps the originals

Before everyone heads home, settle three things out loud. It saves hurt feelings later.

  1. Who carries the tapes home and sends them in. One person, with the list. Splitting the job usually means half the tapes never get done.
  2. Who gets the originals back. Usually each tape goes back to whoever brought it. Write that on the list too.
  3. How the cost gets shared. Some families split it evenly. Some let the person who brought the most tapes pay more. Either is fine, as long as it's decided at the table and not by text in January.

Combining tapes can also lower the cost. At Rewind the price per tape drops as an order grows, and video and audio tapes count together. For example, if three households each sent their tapes separately, 6, 9 and 12 tapes would each be priced at $19 a tape, $513 in all. Sent together as one order of 27 tapes, they'd be $17 each, or $459. Our pricing page has all the tiers.

Getting the tapes home safely

Tapes are sturdier than people think, but a few minutes of care helps:

  • Keep each tape in its case if it has one.
  • Pack them snugly in a sturdy box so they can't slide around. A box wrapped in a towel is better than a loose grocery bag.
  • Ride them home in the car with you rather than leaving the box in a cold or hot car overnight.
  • Put the list in the box.

If you're mailing them, use a sturdy box rather than a padded envelope, label each tape, include a note with your name and phone number, and ship with tracking. Our how it works page has the full packing checklist.

Can the files be ready by Christmas?

Usually, if you move quickly. Turnaround at Rewind is typically 2–3 weeks, depending on how many items you send and how busy things are. Tapes gathered on Thanksgiving weekend and sent in that week give you a good chance of having files before Christmas. If you're cutting it close, call first and ask.

When the files come back, they arrive by a Google Drive link. From there you can download them and share copies with every household on your list, so nobody has to fight over who gets the tapes. If some relatives would rather have something to hold, DVD copies and USB drives are available too.

A simple plan for this Thanksgiving

  • A week before: send the message asking everyone to bring their tapes.
  • At the gathering: number the tapes, make the list, and have the older relatives fill in names and years.
  • Before leaving: decide who sends them in, who gets the originals back, and how the cost is split.
  • That week: pack them up and send them in.

If you'd like help, Rewind transfers VHS and camcorder tapes to digital files by hand here in Spring Hill, Tennessee, for families anywhere in the US, and every original comes back. If you have a mixed box and you're not sure what's in it, ask me before you send it. I'm glad to help you sort it out.

Common questions

Who should keep the original tapes after they're digitized?

Whoever had them before, unless the family agrees otherwise. Once there are digital files, everyone can have a full copy, so the originals mostly become keepsakes. At Rewind every original is returned to the person who sent the order, so decide ahead of time who will pass them back to each household.

What if a relative won't let their tapes leave the house?

That's understandable. Offer to have only their tapes digitized and returned first, or let them send the tapes in themselves so the originals never pass through anyone else's hands. Some people are more comfortable once they know the originals always come back.

Should we test the tapes in an old VCR at Thanksgiving to see what's on them?

It's better not to. An old or dusty VCR can chew up a fragile tape, and a tape that has been stored somewhere damp can be damaged by a quick play. Write down what the label says, note anything that looks wrong, and let the tapes be checked properly before they're played.

Does it cost less to send the whole family's tapes together?

At Rewind it can. The price per tape drops as an order grows, and video and audio tapes count together, so one combined family order often comes out cheaper per tape than several small ones. See the pricing page for the current tiers.

Sources

  1. Family Memories at Thanksgiving (Smithsonian Institution Archives)
  2. Family History Prompts for Thanksgiving Celebrations (American Ancestors)
Jason Smith, owner of Rewind VHS Transfers
Jason Smith

Jason owns Rewind VHS Transfers in Spring Hill, Tennessee, and handles every order himself, for families in all 50 states.

More about Jason

Ready to save your family's tapes?

Get a price in seconds, or call Jason with any questions. Your original tapes always come back.

FREE GAME · PLAYS IN YOUR BROWSER

Play Tape Stack

Drop VHS tapes onto the VCR and build the tallest tower you can. Land a perfect drop to grow your bonus, and watch out for challenge tapes like Fast Forward and Tracking Trouble.

  • Free, nothing to download
  • Tap, click or press Space to drop
  • Chase your high score
Call Contact Jason